Spirit of St. Louis – Pick Your Charity, Pick Your Car

Clayton Court Case Being Watched Closely By School Districts, Parents

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.


A court case has started that could determine the future of every school in St. Louis city and county. It focuses on whether students in unaccredited districts like St. Louis Public Schools, should be able to attend accredited nearby schools and who pays for it. The case is called Turner vs. the Clayton School District and is being heard by Judge David Vincent.

People from St. Louis and beyond will be watching the outcome of this case. It focuses on a 1993 law that says children who attend school in failing districts may transfer to schools in neighboring accredited districts. That statute says the home district not the parents is responsible for tuition and transportation costs.

The original case focused on St. Louis city students who transferred to Clayton schools.

More Info: Read a history of the case from the Clayton School District

This is the second time Judge Vincent has heard the case. In 2008 he ruled in favor of Clayton and St. Louis schools. But the Missouri Supreme Court reversed that decision and ruled in favor of St. Louis parents.

More Info: Read the MO Supreme Court Ruling

The case is expected to last three days. State lawmakers have addressed the issue but have not come up with a solution.

There is concern that if the plaintiffs win there could be serious financial implications for St. Louis city schools. Some are also worried that county schools will become overcrowded if kids from unaccredited schools are permitted to attend.