Ellisville man wins battle over flashing lights to warn of speed traps

Posted on: 2:10 pm, February 3, 2014, by , updated on: 10:28pm, February 3, 2014

(KTVI) – It was a victory for drivers Monday and the use of flashing headlights to warn about police speed traps.

A federal judge’s ruling in St. Louis could have ramifications across the U.S.

Flashing headlights has become a universal symbol meaning “slow-down police radar ahead.”

U.S. District Court Judge, Henry Autrey, of St. Louis issued a preliminary injunction ordering Ellisville Police to halt the policy.

He ruled flashing your headlights was free speech, protected by the First Amendment.

“If you’re at the gas station on the corner and someone says ‘hey be careful over there, there’s a speed trap’, that’s protected speech.  You can’t be ticketed for that.  This is no different,” said Tony Rothert, an attorney for the American Civil Liberty Union.

Ellisville dropped the case long ago, but Elli did not.

The ACLU joined him in filing suit against Ellisville.

In November of 2012, Ellisville Police pulled over Michael Elli, a retired West County resident who hadn’t been accused of a moving violation for more than 35 years, and cited him for flashing his headlights.  A judge later told him the standard fine for it was $1,000.

“In our view that’s speech that’s protected by the First Amendment and it’s also good for the public because it tells people to slow down, to use caution.  That’s never a bad thing,” Rothert said.

George Restovich, an attorney for the City of Ellisville, said the ruling was a moot point for Ellisville Police.

“They specifically took action by way of the chief of police to address this; to say that we will not arrest individuals, we won’t even stop individuals and we certainly won’t prosecute individual. I believe there were maybe 5 tickets that were issued in a similar fashion in the past decade,” Restovich said.

Rothert said he’d heard from people across the country about this case and Autrey’s ruling stood as the prevailing law of the land.

Autrey did not rule on Elli’s claim for modest damages in the case.

Follow me on Twitter:  AndyBankerTV

Facebook:  Andy Banker on Fox 2

Email: Andy.Banker@tvstl.com

 

10 comments

  • Jo Ke says:

    I’d sure like to know what that “new tax” citation or reference is. Doesn’t seem to be listed here
    http://www.sos.mo.gov/elections/2014petitions/14init_pet.asp

  • Christie says:

    Politics aside, it should not be against the law to remind others to follow the law….

    • i remember when i was just a kid traveling from louisiana to mississippi and my uncle would flash his lights and informed me as to why, and it was for this same reason. wow, i never thought that was against the law. and through all my travels, i’ve seen it done and i’ve done it. lol, they were ticked because they couldn’t make their quotas. oh well.

  • Zook1984 says:

    Commercial is way too loud.

  • Rick Long says:

    If people flash their lights are they not getting people to slow down? Is that not why the police are out there setting up speed traps? So its all about the money then…..

  • ean12967 says:

    Finally, a judge with common sense!

  • Mike G says:

    Police try to over the power in everything,…..is wrongfully mind set .
    What are their duties?—–>>keep our peace , keep our safety in our society/community .

  • JC says:

    Nice to see the ACLU do something other than defend criminals and sue over hurt feelings.

    • JayGoldenBeach says:

      It is your incurious, uninformed mindset that has allowed our civil rights to be turned into privileges that can be revoked when we most need them. That is the importance of rights – to protect fom tyranny of the majority that which is unpopular, minority, etc.

  • On your side on this one. Raising taxes on the rich isn’t even what is should be called… let’s go back to the prosperous times of the Clinton era and bring tax rate back to normal.

Comments are closed.