Poll: Trust lacking in Supreme Court over handling of key issues

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

WASHINGTON — With major Supreme Court decisions on health care and same-sex marriage expected this month, many lack trust in the Supreme Court’s handling of those two issues, according to a new CNN/ORC poll.

Yet most approve of the way the court is handling its job generally.

A majority, 52%, say they approve of the way the court is handling its job, while 41% disapprove. That’s an improvement from an even 48% to 48% split two years ago. Still, when Americans are asked how much they trust the court on a range of issues it will be considering this term or the next, the worst ratings come on health care and same-sex marriage. Only about half say they have at least a moderate amount of trust in the court on health care (50%) or same-sex marriage (49%). There is more faith in the Supreme Court on other key issues on the docket, with most saying they trust the court at least a moderate amount on freedom of speech (69%), voting rights (65%) and the death penalty (60%).

The court’s most recent rulings on same-sex marriage have tilted in favor of those who support legal marriages, a growing group among the American public. In this poll, 63% say they believe gay and lesbian couples have a constitutional right to marry. Only 49% said that was a constitutional right as recently as 2010.

The nearly two-thirds who currently say there is a constitutional right for same-sex couples to marry includes about three-quarters of Americans under age 50 (73%) and roughly half of those over age 50 (52%). Majorities of Democrats (74%) and independents (69%) see a constitutional right to marry for same-sex couples, while only 35% of Republicans agree. There is a significant age gap among Republicans and Republican-leaning independents, however, with 59% of those under age 50 saying same-sex couples do have a constitutional right to marry, compared with 36% of Republican-leaners age 50 or older.

On health care, the court upheld a key provision of the law in 2012 and is currently considering whether the law allows subsidies for low- and moderate-income families purchasing insurance through state-run exchanges. In the CNN/ORC poll, 43% of Americans say they favor the law overall, matching its previous high for support last reached in May 2013. But the law remains broadly unpopular, with 55% opposed to it.

Few say they would describe the law as a success thus far, only 11% say so in the poll, while 35% say it has been a failure and 53% say it’s too soon to make a judgment. That split is similar to Americans’ assessment of the law last year around this time, though slightly fewer call it a failure now (39% said so last year).

Supreme Court cases on same-sex marriage and the 2010 health care overhaul have been among the court’s most high-profile rulings in recent years, and opinions on those two issues divide views on the Supreme Court generally. Those who believe that same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry largely approve of the court’s work, 60% approve while 35% disapprove, and those who say there is no such right mostly disapprove, 54% disapprove while 38% approve. Likewise, 61% of those who favor the 2010 health law approve of the way the court is handling its job, 33% disapprove. Among those opposed to the law, views are closely divided: 45% approve and 48% disapprove.

Likewise, Democrats, who are more apt to favor both same-sex marriage and the health care law, are more likely than Republicans to approve of the court’s work. Sixty percent of Democrats approve compared with 40% of Republicans. Independents tilt positive, 52% approve while 41% disapprove. By ideology, moderates actually give the court its best marks, 60% approve, compared with 53% of liberals and 41% of conservatives.

The issue divide carries through when Americans on both sides of the same-sex marriage and health care debates are asked how much they trust the court to handle each issue. On same sex marriage, 63% of those who see a constitutional right for gay or lesbian couples to marry say they trust the court at least a moderate amount on same-sex marriage. Among those who do not see such a right, just 25% have that much trust in the court. On health care, 64% who favor the law trust the court to handle health care policy, only 39% who are opposed to the 2010 law agree.

Public opinion tilts positive on Chief Justice John Roberts, with 33% holding a favorable opinion and 24% unfavorable. Still, a sizable 43% lack an opinion about him. Roberts’ favorable rating is down from 41% holding a positive view in 2012 just after the court upheld the individual mandate in 2010 health law. The decline comes almost entirely among Democrats: 51% held a favorable view then, just 35% do now.

The CNN/ORC poll was conducted by telephone May 29-31 among a random national sample of 1,025 adults.

By Jennifer Agiesta

CNN Polling Director

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.