New Jersey high school under fire for erasing Trump slogans from yearbook
When Grant Berardo, a junior at Wall Township High School in Wall, New Jersey, recently opened his yearbook, he noticed something different about the T-shirt he was wearing in his school photo.
The “TRUMP: Make America Great Again” lettering on his shirt had been digitally removed.
“He was disappointed. This was the first election he has been interested in,” said Grant’s father, Joseph Berardo.
Now the school is facing accusations of censorship, and the parents of three students are looking for answers — and new yearbooks.
“I want the yearbooks to be reissued and I want a letter from the administration explaining why they are reissuing the yearbook,” Joseph Berardo said.
Before the high school’s picture day last fall, Berardo said he and his wife talked to Grant about wearing the shirt and agreed that “as long as the shirt didn’t have drugs or alcohol on it was fine.” When the Berardos got the photo proofs in November, the Trump logo was there and they approved use of the photo in the yearbook.
But when the yearbooks were released this spring, the TRUMP logo was gone. And Grant’s wasn’t the only student’s photo to be altered.
A Donald Trump logo also was missing from junior Wyatt Dobrovich-Fago’s vest. And a quote by Trump was removed from his sister Montana’s freshman class president photo.
Montana had submitted the Trump quote, “I like thinking big. If you are going to be thinking anything, you might as well think big,” to appear underneath her photo.
“I want to know who thought it was okay to do this,” said Janet Dobrovich-Fago, the teens’ mother. “I want the school to seek disciplinary action and to be held accountable.”
School: ‘allegations are ‘disturbing’
Wall Township Public Schools Superintendent Cheryl Dyer sent a letter to parents on June 9, saying she was investigating the matter.
“There is nothing in our student dress code that would prevent a student from expressing his or her political views and support for a candidate for political office via appropriate clothing. Rather, I applaud students for becoming involved in politics and for participation in our democratic society,” she wrote.
“The high school administration was not aware of and does not condone any censorship of political views on the part of our students. This includes statements that they might make or clothing with references to candidates for public office that they might wear.”
The school’s dress code does prohibit references to illegal activity such as use of drugs, alcohol or weapons, she noted.
Both the Berardos and the Dobrovich-Fagos want the school to issue new yearbooks with the original photos and quotes.
“There is an opportunity to use this as a teaching moment for the kids, and for the teachers as well,” Joseph Berardo said. “This is a First Amendment, freedom of speech issue.”
In a statement released June 10, Dyer said the school district’s staffers “strongly value the principles of free speech and inquiry in our schools and society, viewing them as the bedrock upon which our community and educational system is built. The allegations referenced above are disturbing, and any inappropriate challenge to these principles will be rectified as swiftly and thoroughly as possible. The actions of the staff involved will be addressed as soon as the investigation is concluded.”
‘This is for every student’
Dyer said neither she nor the school’s administrators were involved in the alteration of the photos.
“We were not aware of it until the books were distributed, we do not condone it, and we working on a remedy to the issue,” she told CNN Sunday. “I cannot discuss personnel matters, but I take this very seriously and it will be addressed appropriately.”
Donald Trump was not completely removed from the yearbook. One page mentions the 2016 presidential election.
Joseph Berardo said he asked the school whether students’ shirts supporting Hillary Clinton or Bernie Sanders had been changed but “we haven’t seen that. No one has said anything, but it’s still the same issue.”
“This is not just about my kids. This is for every student,” said Janet Dobrovich-Fago.
Both families plan to meet with the principal and the yearbook adviser this week.