‘He is just a menace.’ Indiana man arrested seven times in six months

One Indiana man has enough mugshots to populate an Instagram account. They're all recent, and law enforcement is not happy about it.

Johnson County Sheriff Duane Burgess said this repeat offender was arrested this week and is not leaving his jail anytime soon.

“He is just a menace to Johnson County citizens,” Burgess said.

Burgess is talking about 35-year-old Steven Wagers. Wagers has been arrested seven times in the last six months, including twice within three days last Friday and Monday. Records show Wagers has been arrested nearly 30 times over the last 17 years. Most of his arrests are for thefts and drug possession.

“Every time we catch him and we arrest him he’s got some kind of narcotics that he’s in possession of,” Burgess said. “It’s been an occurrence where I’m walking in the jail and he’s being released and I’m like ‘Stay out of jail, Steven.’ And he’s returning that next day.”

Late Friday night, Wagers was arrested on suspicion of stealing a car in Greenwood. Deputies said Wagers led them on a chase and fought with officers when they caught up to him. They said they found a syringe and pain pills on Wagers when they arrested him.

Monday morning, Wagers was out of jail and police responded to a call in the same area about a suspicious man in a front yard. Responding officers recognized Wagers as he ran away from them again, police said. During the foot chase, they said Wagers jumped a fence before sitting down in a lawn chair. Police said they found him with a bag of methamphetamines.

When Burgess heard of the latest arrest Monday, he quickly sought a court order to hold Wagers without bond. He said the move was intended to keep Wagers locked up so he couldn’t go out and commit any more crimes pending a court appearance.

“You don’t wish that on anybody,” Burgess said. “You wish a person to be productive and he just can’t be.”

At one point, Wagers was sent to a recovery home for people with substance abuse problems, but he only spent eight days there.

“I believe he was showing staff some pornographic material,” Burgess said. “Got him kicked out of it.”

Burgess said Wagers’ multiple run-ins with the law point to the need for stronger laws and sentencing guidelines for repeat offenders. In 2017, Wagers was convicted in a string of roughly 20 car break-ins. He was sentenced to 4.5 years in jail, but was released less than a year later. The early release was the result of Wagers already serving about 500 days in jail while awaiting trial. Wagers was allowed to serve half the remaining sentence due to good behavior while he was incarcerated.

Burgess said some people go to jail because they make a mistake. But Wagers has demonstrated an inability to turn his life around, Burgess said.

“There are people who continue to make mistakes and they need to be incarcerated and they do not need to be on the street,” Burgess said. “And that’s where our legislators need to enact stronger laws and sentencing guidelines.”

State lawmakers are currently considering a bill to send more felony offenders to state prisons instead of local jails. House Bill 1078 would send violent or repeat Level 6 felony offenders to the Department of Corrections. Level 6 felony offenders have been held in county jails for the last several years as a result of sweeping criminal justice reform measures enacted at the statehouse.

Burgess said he believes passage of the bill could be a first step toward holding repeat offenders longer and easing some crowding at county jails.

Steven Wagers remains in the Johnson County Jail, held on no bond. A trial for a previous case scheduled for this week has been rescheduled in light of his two most recent arrests.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.