Judge Revises Wording For Mo. Health Care Measure

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — A Missouri judge ruled Tuesday that Democratic Secretary of State Robin Carnahan had provided an unfair and insufficient summary of a health care ballot measure to appear before voters this fall and instead ordered election authorities to use an alternative description backed by Republicans.

The ruling marked a victory for Lt. Gov. Peter Kinder and fellow Republicans in the Legislature, who referred the measure to the November ballot but then sued to contest the summary drafted by Carnahan’s office. The ballot measure focuses on “health insurance exchanges,” the online marketplaces required under President Barack Obama’s health care law.

Cole County Judge Dan Green heard arguments Tuesday in the lawsuit and later issued a brief, two-page ruling declaring that “the ballot summary prepared and certified by Secretary of State Robin Carnahan is not fair and sufficient.” Green did not elaborate on the reasons leading him to that conclusion.

Carnahan’s original ballot summary stated: “Shall Missouri law be amended to deny individuals, families, and small businesses the ability to access affordable health care plans through a state-based health benefit exchange unless authorized by statute, initiative or referendum or through an exchange operated by the federal government as required by the federal health care act?”

Attorney Jay Kanzler, who represented Republican officeholders in the lawsuit, had argued to the judge that the state cannot deny Missourians access to health insurance exchanges, regardless of what happens to the measure in the November election.

“To use the word ‘deny’ where something can never be denied is illogical unless its use was intended to mislead or influence the voters against the ballot proposal,” Kanzler had said.

Green ordered Carnahan to use a revised ballot summary that had been suggested by the Republican plaintiffs. The new summary states: “Shall Missouri law be amended to prohibit the Governor or any state agency, from establishing or operating state based health insurance exchanges unless authorized by a vote of the people or by the Legislature?”

Kinder praised the swift ruling as “an enormous victory for Missouri voters” that “gives proof to the clear bias in Carnahan’s summary.”

“Judge Green’s ruling substantiates our claim that Secretary Carnahan’s ballot summary does not pass the laugh test,” Kinder said in a written statement.

Carnahan’s office said Tuesday that the original summary is fair and sufficient and the revised version would “provide Missouri voters with less information about the impact of the proposal and how Missouri individuals, families and small businesses can access affordable health care.”

Officials said they are reviewing the decision to determine the next step.

A spokeswoman for Attorney General Chris Koster, whose office defended the ballot summary, had no immediate comment on whether the ruling would be appealed.

During court arguments Tuesday, Deputy Solicitor General Jeremiah Morgan had defended the summary. He said it was clear that in passing the measure, lawmakers were trying to “squeeze” efforts to establish a state-based insurance exchange and possibly a federal exchange.

The federal health care law, which Obama signed in 2010, requires states to either create their own health insurance exchanges by 2014 or else the federal government will run one for them.

If approved by voters, the Missouri ballot measure would bar the governor or other Missouri officials from creating a health insurance exchange without approval from voters or the Legislature. It also would prohibit state departments from taking federal money to set up the online marketplace, which is intended under the federal health care law to help consumers shop for and compare insurance plans.

Morgan had argued that simply because a summary could be written differently — or even arguably more accurately — did not mean it was insufficient or unfair.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

About FOX 2 News

FOX 2 and KPLR 11 in St. Louis cover the news in Missouri and Illinois. There are over 68 hours of live news and local programming on-air each week. Our website and live video streams operate 24/7. Download our apps for alerts and follow us on social media for updates in your feed.

President Harry Truman said: “It is amazing what you can accomplish if you do not care who gets the credit.” That spirit is alive and well at Fox 2. Our teamwork is on display each and every day.

Our news slogan is: “Coverage You Can Count On.” We quite frankly are too busy to worry about who gets the credit. Our main concern is serving the viewer.

We go where the stories take us. Whether it be Washington, D.C when a Belleville man opened fire during a congressional baseball game practice or to Puerto Rico where local Ameren crews restored power after more than 5 months in the dark.

Coverage You Can Count On means “Waking up your Day” with our top-rated morning show. From 4:00 am-10:00 am we are leading the way with breaking news. But our early morning crew also knows how to have some fun! Our strong commitment to the communities we serve is highlighted with our Friday neighborhood shows.

Our investigative unit consists of three reporters. Elliott Davis focuses on government waste, Chris Hayes is our investigative reporter, and Mike Colombo is our consumer reporter. They work in unison with the news department by sharing resources and ideas.

We continue to cover breaking news aggressively and relied on our seasoned journalists to make a difference with the stories we covered. The shooting of Arnold Police Officer Ryan O’Connor is just one example of that. Jasmine Huda was the only reporter who had exclusive access to the O’Connor family during his amazing rehabilitation in Colorado.

Last, but certainly not least, FOX 2 and KPLR 11 are committed to covering local politics. We host debates among candidates and have the most extensive presidential election coverage. Our commitment to politics isn’t just during an election year. We produce two political shows that air every weekend.


Latest News

More News